The Rolling Pin
Drag box to select area
The Rolling Pin is a bakery located in Village Plaza on route 25a. The bakery has been praised in Newsday for its signature wedding cakes and for being one of the newspaper's top-ten favorite things about Long Island. The Rolling Pin has an extensive selection of cookies, cakes, pastries and tarts. Cakes come in fifty-five varieties, pastries in forty-two and breads in sixteen; all goods are made from scratch.
1387 Route 25a, East Setauket, NY 11733
- Hours: Mon - Fri, 9:30am - 5pm; Sat - Sun, closed
- Hours: Mon - Sat, 6am - 7pm; Sun, 6am - 5pm
- Accessible: yes