.
Feedback

Deer Sightings in Local Villages on the Upswing

Residents in Old Field and Poquott have been noticing more deer in the area lately.

Old Field resident Carole Trottere can appreciate the sight of a deer, as she noted in she saw near her home.

Lately, though, she said it has been happening more frequently. She often sees hoof prints in the sand on the beach near her home and even saw a family of deer passing across her driveway recently.

"They do not always seem to be keeping to the early evening and dawn hours either, because I see them often in the middle of the day," Trottere said. "Last year it was a pretty rare – and always magical – occurrence to see deer, but this year I see them with much more frequency."

In Old Field and Poquott, officials have taken note of the increase in deer sightings. Particularly in Old Field, the population of deer seems to be causing a nuisance when it comes to preserving the vegetation in the village.

Resident Bruce Feller volunteered to look into the deer problem, and even found a company that deals with deer control in humane ways.

According to that company, SavATree, which has locations in Southampton and Old Brookville, a deer repelling spray can be applied to plants to discourage the deer from nibbling, and a proprietary system using ultrasound technology may also be effective.

"Unfortunately, there appears not to be a 'silver bullet,' but rather a range of methods to reduce such damage. In combination they can help, depending on deer population, winter snow cover, and other variables," Feller wrote in an open letter to Old Field residents posted on the village's website.

Meanwhile, in Poquott, deer sightings are becoming more frequent, but village residents have not experienced the loss of plants to the deer population.

"We're seeing more deer in Poquott," mayor Barbara Donovan said in an interview Monday. "I haven't had any problems where residents have called to say the deer are eating the vegetation."

Though not specifically a problem in Poquott, Donovan also noted that deer crossing Route 25A have sometimes hit cars in the region where the road curves around the intersection with Washington Street on the Setauket/Port Jefferson border.

Have you noticed an increase in deer sightings in Three Village? Share your experiences as a comment below.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Three Village Patch? Find your Local Patch »

John Blatny November 15, 2011 at 04:32 pm
We live in the "M" section of Stony Brook, a far cry from the wooded areas of Poquott but fairly close to the University and the old Flowerfields property. Last year we discovered a fawn in our back yard. Initially she got spooked, started running and bouncing off our fence several times. Eventually, we were able to open a gate and gently steer her towards the front. She took off in the direction of Coed Park, where I suspect she came from.
Lily Zajc November 15, 2011 at 05:13 pm
I was in Island Estates in Setauket and peered right into the eyes of a deer over the fence in a sump. It leads to a forested area, so I'm assuming it came from there. When I finished my run, it was still there.
Pam Botway November 15, 2011 at 05:20 pm
Last night I spotted a female deer darting across Possum Lane near the walking trail by Sheep Pasture Road. At first I thought it was a dog. A friend spotted several on Woodchuck Lane the other night as well. Last winter there were two in the greenbelt behind Bunny Lane. They seemed to be regulars but I think people were feeding them. I think they live around the sand pit. I see more at West Meadow beach lately. This is the first time in 20 years though that I have seen them in the neighborhood.
Terri Arrigon November 15, 2011 at 09:27 pm
Several sightings on Strong's Neck.
John Blatny November 15, 2011 at 11:28 pm
Feeding the deer is truly a bad idea. I was spoke to the police officer who responded to my call, who then recounted another incident last year in a home off Old Town Road, where the family had been feeding deer in the area. The officer told me that an adult buck, ran through a sliding glass door and injured itself. Consequently, the police had no alternative but to shoot the animal.
Adam Newman November 16, 2011 at 12:05 am
Next Patch photo contest: deer pictures???
Bill Seydel November 16, 2011 at 03:00 am
As the population of Deer increase due to the lack of habitat left from urban sprawl, we will only have more deer sightings. The result will be more deer dying of starvation each winter and a more unhealthy emaciated population of deer over time. Too bad the few spots left in Three Village for legal hunting have been posted and no longer available to hunt. As these deer continue to repopulate with no controls in place, we will have more deer involved motor vehicle accidents as well. I just hope the lack of legal hunting areas don't result in the personal injury of our friends and neighbors in our community.
Shawn Clap November 16, 2011 at 03:02 pm
The "emaciated" deer myth used to justify hunting is laughable. First off, the deer population on Long Island is no where near large enough to deplete its food supply, even in the winter months. Secondly, hunters look to kill the biggest bucks with the largest antlers, not allegedly "starving" deer.
You are NOT doing a public service by killing deer in their own habitat.
Heather Costa November 16, 2011 at 03:40 pm
We have seen several deer in the past year in the woods next to our home in Stony Brook, Head of the Harbor area.. We enjoy the sightings, but fear we won't see them any more along with other wildlife as the 4 acres next to us is under contract and there is a permit and building plans in place.
Pam Botway November 16, 2011 at 03:47 pm
I used to live in Marin County north of San Francisco. There was a huge deer problem on Angel Island. While valid comments are being made here, this was a hotly studied issue out there and maybe we can learn from it. Read this link: http://www.tws-west.org/transactions/Goldsmith.pdf If you dig a little deeper into the history, you will see how feeding vs not feeding, hunting vs not hunting, even sterlizing and moving them doesn't always end well. Angel Island has a rich history. We can take some pointers from this.
Bob M. November 16, 2011 at 08:02 pm
We began seeing small groups of deer in 2008 on the western border of the "S" section in Stony Brook. They forage mostly in the wooded area behind the Unitarian and Christian Churchs on Nichols Rd. On rare occasions, they also visit yards bordering the woodland. It's amazing how many animal species we've observed in such a small area. Aside from the usual suspects, we've observed tortoise, owl, hawk, snakes and even a salamander.
TJRA November 17, 2011 at 02:16 am
I read the report. Very inconclusive, but it seems that the idea of sterilization was not fully explored or implemented. Any more info on that approach?
LivingSmall November 17, 2011 at 03:19 am
About 9 years ago, as I drove west on 25A a little before sunset, just before Main St and the SFD a deer bounded across the westbound lane and was struck by the car in front of me. It tumbled over the hood, sprang to it's feet and ran into the SFD parking lot. I pulled into the lot, ran in to tell the dispatcher, fearing an accident. My son remained in the car and witnessed the deer walk in front of my car, confused, stumbling, but it continued across Old Town and west through the parking lots on 25A. It came to rest in the hose storage area of the Setauket car wash, where it was euthanized as the injuries incurred when it was struck.
Fast Forward to Wednesday, Nov. 9 -- early in the morning a deer was struck by a car on Hallock Ave in front of the Wunderbar Deli. I've seen deer on Stony Brook Rd by the train trestle, on Hollow Rd in Stony Brook -- closer to Christian, and on my own street in Stony Brook not far from 25A, as well as at Gyrodyne and in the fields on 25A in St James. Bill is the only other person to bring up the reality of deer vs. motor vehicle. Mercifully none of our family members, friends or neighbors have been in such an accident...yet.
Pam Botway November 17, 2011 at 05:48 am
DON’T feed the deer. It turns out it is against the law. “Supplemental feeding is often proposed as a means to improve the condition of deer or to take pressure off other food resources. Regulations established in 2002 due to concerns about Chronic Wasting Disease completely prohibit the feeding of wild deer in New York. The following information is presented simply to describe the potential effects of feeding…http://www.dec.ny.gov/docs/wildlife_pdf/ctguide07.pdf. Another important consideration is that fed deer become increasingly tame and more likely to tolerate human activity. This increases the likelihood of deer/human interactions and conflicts such as personal injury, damage to personal property and motor vehicle collisions.”
I'll add part 2 to this in the next comment since it doesn't fit here.
Pam Botway November 17, 2011 at 05:54 am
This link explains the outcome of the original link describing birth control and relocation being a dismal failure. http://footlooseforays.com/chronicles/?p359
Another article argues against relocating deer. “The late Dr. Seirg Krasheninnikow — of the University of Pennsylvania—who was considered an outstanding scientist in the field of nutrition said, "Animals living in a certain vicinity have in their mouths and stomachs those bacteria which break down foods found in that area. If deer are released in an area where the majority of plants are different, the introduced animals cannot digest them" (Gamble 62-63).” http://www.wonews.com/t-FeatureArticle-TomElsbury-RelocatedDeer-103108.aspx. They are beautiful creatures best admired from afar. Keep in mind that they carry ticks. Just one more reason to discourage feeding near your property.
Susan Camenzuli November 17, 2011 at 12:04 pm
I live in the S Section, last year I looked out my window and saw two deer eating my hostas on the front lawn, they finished and walked back towards the woods which are about a block away. We also have seen wild turkey crossing the street.
Terri Arrigon November 17, 2011 at 01:26 pm
I don't think the flora upstate, for example, would be that different, would it? Definitely feeding is a very bad idea. Thanks for all the info you are contributing to this discussion, Pam.
Pam Botway November 17, 2011 at 04:14 pm
This would be a good opportunity for our state officials to put together an educational forum at Stony Brook University.
Call in the experts to enlighten us. We should all be on the same page. Education is key.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Tc June 18, 2013 at 04:59 pm
Justme.. Even if everyone voted no the raises were locked. By voting no programs would have beenRead More decimated more and more teachers given pink slips. The problem here is the BOE giving the union these contracts. It's time to STOP THE MADNESS!!
JJ Smith June 18, 2013 at 07:04 pm
And the candidate for the BOE ran unopposed. We have no to blame but ourselves.
justme June 19, 2013 at 06:52 am
Yes TC change is difficult but it has to start somewhere. What motivation does the BOE have toRead More change when we keep passing the budgets? Budgets have to fail, programs have to be cut before there will be any union negotiations. Many have to lose their jobs before they will allow their pay to be cut. Sounds harsh but it's reality. Our children will survive cuts, be educated and successful - even with less programs.